1. U.S. Elementary Education : What Parents Need to Know
    Dismiss Notice

Immigrant Wives' Visa Status Keeps Them Out of Workplace

Discussion in 'Immigration Matters' started by sonal, Feb 19, 2006.

  1. sonal

    sonal Junior IL'ite

    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    Recent article that was published in the Washington post.

    Immigrant Wives' Visa Status Keeps Them Out of Workplace

    [size=-1]By S. Mitra Kalita
    Washington Post Staff Writer
    Monday, October 3, 2005; A01

    <NITF>Some rooms are empty, most walls are bare, but the mantel in Hanuma Samavedam's new Loudoun County home seems conspicuously crowded. There, amid family photos and knickknacks from her native India, sit the academic medals and trophies she racked up in a previous life.

    She turns to them often to remember what it was to feel proud, purposeful, independent.

    She arrived in the United States in 2001, riding the coattails of her husband's H-1B visa, a guest-worker program for highly skilled professionals like him -- not that Samavedam wasn't. In India, she earned an MBA and worked as a finance manager at an accounting firm. But once she married, U.S. immigration policy put her in a different category: dependent.

    For thousands of women like her, the word defines more than visa status. It defines them.

    "When I came here, everyone said with my qualifications, I would get a job," Samavedam said. "I had a very good impression of America, that there are equal rights for women. ... It's not that I feel lonely. I feel unnecessary."

    While spouses of diplomats and business executives can legally work in the United States, those married to computer programmers and software engineers -- the job descriptions most often associated with the H1B visas -- cannot. According to the State Department, nearly half a million such visas have been issued in the past four years, while about 300,000 visas have been issued for their dependents.

    "Having a trailing spouse in today's day and age is not dealt with," said immigration lawyer Elizabeth Espin Stern of Baker & McKenzie LLP. "We've neglected these individuals and their families. It is an arrogant stance and an insensitive one."

    Since the mid-1990s, as the tech industry successfully lobbied Congress to increase the number of professional visas, hundreds of thousands of guest workers have entered the United States, mostly young men from India and China. In what has become an almost formulaic journey in the United States, the workers tend to arrive single and return to their homelands to marry, bringing their wives back to the United States on the H4 visa issued to dependents.

    In Samavedam's case -- in which her horoscope and that of Raghu Donepudi were matched, their family backgrounds compared, and their personalities deemed compatible after a 15-minute conversation -- immigration status never entered discussions.

    "That topic never came up. He said he had an active life, that he played golf, cricket," said Samavedam, whose hair parting is streaked with red vermillion powder to show she is married. "When I told him about my life in India, he said here it would also be the same."

    Instead, she discovered a world initially confined to their Stamford, Conn., apartment. As Donepudi left at 7 a.m., Samavedam tried to stay asleep so she wouldn't have to face a day "sitting idle," as she describes it. She rattled off how she kept busy: CNN, an afternoon nap, elaborate homemade meals, several immigration Web sites.

    Nearly five years later, she lives in a spacious house in a South Riding development, but the routines remain the same. The recent birth of a son, Madhav, helped break the monotony, but Samavedam said her desire to work remains strong. She said she dreams of having her own money and of juggling day care drop-offs with morning meetings.

    "Her career has already vegetated for four years," said Donepudi, whose application for a green card is among a backlog of 300,000 cases in the Labor Department. "We're living 50 percent of our full potential."

    Some dependent spouses have been able to find employers to sponsor H-1B visas for them. Those work visas allow holders to stay in the country for up to six years, at which point they must return home or have their employers file green card applications. Once they have received green cards, workers and their families can live and work in the United States freely, but getting a green card can take years.

    Advocates of more restrictive immigration laws say extending work authorization to dependents would take jobs away from Americans. Christopher S. Bentley, a spokesman for U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, part of the Department of Homeland Security, said that he empathized with the immigrant spouses but that they entered the United States knowing their status would be temporary and dependent.

    "It's a choice they made," Bentley said.

    Lawyer and immigrant advocate Shivali Shah, who surveyed 70 H-4 visa holders, found that all but one of them would work if they could. And dozens of interviews with respondents revealed high rates of depression, isolation and loneliness. "The H-4 visa is taking some of the brightest women in India and turning them into housewives here," Shah said. "Their lives as professionals would have thrived in India but here, they are just somebody's wife. Not being allowed to work is skewing the power balance of the marriage."

    As the co-founder of Kiran, a South Asian women's organization in North Carolina, Shah observed that an unusually high number of battered women seeking help were on dependent visas. Last year, she launched the survey with the hopes of using its results to lobby on their behalf. The dependent women, battered or not, have few advocates, Shah said. Immigration lawyers represent employers or workers, and other organizations tend to rally behind poor, undocumented migrants.

    "Your most productive years for work out of college were spent e-mailing all day and collecting recipes from the Internet and waiting for your husband to come home so he can take you grocery shopping," she said.

    Some women are so unhappy that they'd rather leave the United States -- and their husbands. After Brazilian native Marselha Goncalves married a Frenchman on an H-1B visa, she felt her world shrink down to the walls of their Arlington apartment. Night after night, Bruno Margerin found his bride on the couch crying. They bickered over stupid things like how much salt she had put in dinner.

    To save the marriage, Margerin told his wife -- who had a master's degree in international peace and conflict resolution from American University -- to get as far away from him as she needed to find work.

    Goncalves accepted a job this year in Haiti with a division of the United Nations.

    "I'd rather be in a place where the two of us can work," she said during a recent visit to Arlington. "The hardest thing for me is to be apart. But here, I don't feel fulfilled. The Food Network cannot be the highlight of my day. We live in a capitalist world, so for you to be recognized, you have to get a paycheck."

    Some women work illegally, while others fill their time on Web sites and listservs for dependent spouses, where they can swap recipes and status reports on green card applications. There is even a Yahoo group for dependent spouses in Dallas.

    To combat the silence of suburbia that seemed so at odds with the bustling, crowded India she left, Bindu Reddy went to the library and volunteered at a school when she arrived in the United States. Sometimes the former special-education teacher browsed job listings on the Internet, knowing that few schools would sponsor her work permit.

    She says she still wonders what would have happened if she had not immigrated. She probably would have opened her own school by now. Her house would probably dwarf the Germantown two-bedroom apartment she calls home.

    Before coming to the United States in 1998, the Reddys lived in London -- where spouses like Bindu are given work permits.

    Like Samavedam, Bindu Reddy has been waiting years for her husband to get his green card so she can begin to have choices again. In a region where economists estimate that a family of three needs to earn $47,000 to $62,000 a year to get by, the Reddys, like many U.S. families, would like two incomes to earn money for savings or extras, such as dinners out or DVDs for the boys.

    "We feel not for ourselves but for our kids. They ask us, 'Why can't we move?'" said Reddy, who has a master's degree in special education. "My son asks me, 'When are you going to work? I want to go to day care, too.' Sometimes I shout at him for saying that, and I feel bad."

    In the case of India, where matchmakers do not hesitate to ask potential mates details about their salaries, skin color, even weight, observers say women's families are getting more inquisitive about immigration status. Because of a robust Indian economy and advances they have made in the workplace, fewer Indian women want to leave to become housewives, said Murugavel Janakiraman, chief executive of BharatMatrimony Group, a global matchmaking service.

    "In the late 1990s, the people were more interested in going abroad and wanted a foreign groom. They were not really concerned about whether they could get a job," Janakiraman said in a phone interview from the southern Indian city of Chennai. "Now they prefer to be in India."

    Mostly via e-mail, Hanuma Samavedam keeps up with news of former colleagues and the various job opportunities they are finding in India. Some have been promoted two, even three, times since she left. She acknowledged the education her son will get in the United States and the job opportunities for her husband. But she wondered aloud whether her sacrifice is worth it.

    "I became a housewife here, but my mind wants to work," she said. "If I get a job today, I will like this country, too."

    </NITF><!-- start the copyright for the articles -->
    © 2005 The Washington Post Company​
    Last edited by a moderator: Apr 12, 2006

  2. sofiya

    sofiya New IL'ite

    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    Wow! Reading this mail is like reading your own story if you're on an H4 visa. I guess each and everyone of us who are on H4 status share the same sentiments as put forth in this post but there is little we can do besides sharing these sentiments and giving moral support to each other.

    With the H1 visa quota filling on the first day this year hopes, dreams and ambitions have gone down in the dumps. But we all continue to live with it as in the story with a ray of hope in our hearts that someday things will get better.

    Thanx for sharing Sonal.
  3. SimplyIsha

    SimplyIsha New IL'ite

    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    Well, I am going to get married in the US soon and reading about the plight of all the H4 visa holders really scares me..Here in India, my days are so full of work,fun,job, family etc...I am really dreading the idleness, the loneliness i shall have to face in a new country, new house, with no friends, family, JOB, independent life anything....

    But i do wonder at times that when Indians hold such a strong presence there, cant all the H1-B visa holders collectively raise their voice and respresent the woes fo their wives to the immigration authorities? cant the H4 wives run some kind of a campaign to draw teh attention of the authorities?
  4. Aarushi

    Aarushi Platinum IL'ite

    Likes Received:
    Trophy Points:
    Good point Ishita!

    The legal immigrants in US are planning to hold a rally in Washington DC on September 18th, to highlight this issue as well as that of the green card backlog (which in turn creates this mess for H4's).

    All those ladies whose husbands have applied for a green card and are waiting for it to come in order to begin working, have a long long wait ahead of them.

    The only sad part is that very few of them are actually willing to do something about it.

    The H4's are badly hit by the visa backlogs hampering their ability to work, and the rally in DC is a part of the fight against this injustice. But many of the H4's (affected by the backlog..I'm not talking of all the H4's here) will not be joining this rally.

    The strength of the rally lies in numbers...and many are going to turn up. But for every person that says that their life is getting wasted sitting at home because they cannot work, but does not want to go to DC for a few hours to hold a placard and register their protest, there is one member less from the legal immigrant community showing their protest.

    Through this post I would like to again ask the fence sitters to please make a point to go to the DC rally on Sept 18th. A few hours and a few dollars are worth getting your work permit in a reasonable amount of time rather than 6-10 years.

Share This Page