Eyeliner in shape of lipstick

Does the Himalaya kajal smudge? I have stopped using kajal for this reason. Even high end brands smudge a bit. That's why I only use liquid eyeliner nowadays.

Thanks,
MLP1

 

Thanks for your response!

 

Lakme iconic doesn't smudge
Mabeline collosal kajal too doesn't smudge.

 

Thanks for your response. Lakme iconic smudged for me. Maybelline I don't prefer because it tests its cosmetics on animals.

 

Personally for me, these lipstick packaged kajals-Himalaya, Shahanaz Hussain, Lotus Herbals, VLCC, have never worked. The only plus is that they offer an intense black color but since I have an oily skin, the kajal smudges after a while and I look like a zombie.
For years now, my savior is Maybelline Collosal Kajal.

 

Lakme eyeconic kajal is the best or maybeline colossal kajal u can use it

these are the eyeliners the way u described.

 

@desichica

Yes, Maybelline's collosal kajal is by far the most hassle free no-nonense kajal. I don't step outside without kajal and this is my HG kajal since so many years now. I also despise pencil kajals as sharpening is a pain in the ass, besides these have a very rough tip if sharpened in haste.