1. Have an Interesting Snippet to Share : Click Here
    Dismiss Notice

Parenting – A Boon Or A Curse

Discussion in 'Snippets of Life (Non-Fiction)' started by Bhargavi03, Sep 21, 2017.

  1. Bhargavi03

    Bhargavi03 Gold IL'ite

    Messages:
    143
    Likes Received:
    169
    Trophy Points:
    100
    Gender:
    Female
    Child birth is undoubtedly one of the most euphoric moments in any parents’ lives that bring the tears of joy in every eye. While we celebrate this jubilant occasion, a large part of us remain oblivious or miss to notice that big package of responsibility and challenges posed to parenting that comes along with this little cupid. I am no expert in child or teen psychology, still in my nascent stages of parenting (raising my six year old son), desired to take this forum to unleash some of my first hand experiences on raising children (albeit my purview to this could be limited on practical end but profound on theoretical and observations from near and dear ones) and on a larger scale wanted to share something that perturbed me in the recent past.

    A couple of weeks ago as I was randomly surfing through some news on the internet, I inadvertently bumped into this amazing lecture delivered by a psychology professor from Harvard university (translated into an article) about the mentality of adolescent and teenage kids of the recent era across the globe. A plethora of topics was covered that includes the exposure, knowledge, interests, focus etc. of these kids but something that captured my attention and left me into deep thoughts was about the high level of mental and emotional sensitivity of these kids, lack of endurance to achieve success, a large extent of being an introvert working mostly in a covert manner and the inevitable peer & parental pressure on them.

    With the rapid modernization of our lives most of the families these days breaks down into nuclear shells. A majority of these nuclear families resort to having only single kids (owing to lack of time to dedicate for these kids growth/financial or economic factors/personal choice etc.). These highly pampered kids evolve into emotionally weak and sensitive ones, dependent and unable to accept failures or disappointments in life. These mental/psychological conditions of course cannot be generalized or categorized only for single kids as it happens for kids with siblings too.

    Recently a teenage girl probably sixteen or seventeen years old from the family of a prominent celebrity in the Indian film industry ran away from her home and this news spread like wild fire becoming the cynosure of media and people. I happened to watch this press conference meeting on YouTube set up by her mother and aunt pleading the media and the police to help them find their daughter. While they believed that their daughter was abducted and did not return from school, in reality she had left her home without notification, furtively, traveled all the way to a neighboring city and found shelter in some Christian hostel with the limited cash that she managed to carry from her home. The poignant speech given by her distraught mother crying and begging for her daughter to come back ripped me apart. Although I do not intend to be judgemental or come with some preconceived notions of shifting the blame entirely on the child or the parents owing to the lack of clarity of what really happened to the girl that triggered her do something like this, yet this girl’s action is scary, deplorable and stigmatic. This is not something novel, there are similar incidents happening in many places with teenage or younger kids running away from home or even worse end up becoming suicidal leaving their parents behind into an unfathomable plight inflicted with utmost agony that might probably haunt them for the rest of their lives.

    I was left in grave shock and disbelief of how this girl could put her parents through this dismal phase. Or rather what factors forced this girl to take this extreme risk/step in her life that faltered her mother and father as parents? Is it that academic pressure from parents or peers unable to cope up with the challenges of this competitive world or is it the intolerance towards negative criticism that is embarrassing or daunting or is it the impatience towards attaining success (as they want everything easy and quick) or is it a dejection due to failure or it could range over myriad other reasons starting from a bullying at school, physical or personal issues like parental arguments or may be a divorce at home. Well, the reasons are many but the question here is how do we help our kids handle them?

    There is no specific rule book to parenting as some tips and tricks might help in a few instances but may not help others. When our kids commit a mistake definitely reprimanding them by physical or verbal abuse is never a solution. It might only make the situation worse. Embracing them with love and compassion and guiding them by pointing out their mistakes at the right time politely might help. Of course we should also be cognizant of the fact that the love and affection we shower on them should not come at a cost of spoiling our kids. So it’s a way of smart parenting that probably we all, as better parents should learn. We should help them comprehend that a negative feedback is not detrimental rather instrumental on a positive front aiding in their personality growth and development. We should motivate them that failures are only stepping stones to success, that it is perfectly OK if they are not a laureate or a genius, make them realize that no one is perfect here which would in turn encourage them to evolve from their naive and vulnerable self into a more confident, strong and a better individual ready to face and fight the savage reality of life.

    As a closing note, parenting is certainly a boon, a blessing in disguise and not a threat. Like how every child is unique in their own way so is every parent. Each of them have their own style of raising their kids and are proud about it. It’s just that we should help our kids and as ourselves not succumb under pressure, take life in a positive spirit and emerge as better humans!!
     
    Loading...

  2. Bhargavi03

    Bhargavi03 Gold IL'ite

    Messages:
    143
    Likes Received:
    169
    Trophy Points:
    100
    Gender:
    Female
    Hey folks watch out the space for snippets with my new article - "Parenting - A Boon Or A Curse".
    I am writing after a long hiatus and hoping to see some interesting/debatable feedback.

    Cheers,
    Bhargavi
     
  3. Rihana

    Rihana Moderator Staff Member IL Hall of Fame

    Messages:
    12,503
    Likes Received:
    30,273
    Trophy Points:
    540
    Gender:
    Female
    Many interesting points raised, Bhargavi. Almost all the chapters of parenting touched upon.

    Since you are fine with feedback that debates, here are some thoughts that came to mind:

    The girl who ran away and found shelter in a Christian hostel - yes, it is a very difficult event for the parents. One cannot imagine the pain of dealing with it, and the hours or days of not knowing what happened to child. But, if the story has a relatively happy ending - girl found safe and unharmed, unabducted, it is not the end of the world. Girl and parents, maybe with the help of a trusted mediator or a professional counselor can address what needs change.

    On a general note, modern parenting and modern analysis of parenting places too much scrutiny on parents and their results. I read in another older thread here: parents often blame themselves too much or take too much credit for a child that turns out to be a problem child or an achiever.

    Sometimes, I long for being a parent in the era when people didn't read too many books, articles on parenting, and did not have to be like expert UN level diplomat in dealings with child.
     
  4. Bhargavi03

    Bhargavi03 Gold IL'ite

    Messages:
    143
    Likes Received:
    169
    Trophy Points:
    100
    Gender:
    Female
    Hi Rihana, thank you for your thought provoking comments/feedback. I totally agree to your part of psychological/emotional counseling to be undertaken by parents and kids who probably undergo this kind of a traumatic experiences. As much as it affects the parents it does affect the child's mental sanity on a long run. So taking appropriate help is highly advisable.
    Coming to your general note as there is a saying "Ignorance is bliss", it certainly is convenient and peaceful to lead a life like our parents did 3 decades ago, a world sans technology and its harmful exposure/addiction to kids, a world with probably lesser child abuse or crime rates or maybe again here comes the ignorance of our parents of not been exposed to such cruel happenings around .. although pressure of education was always a running problem now and then, a lot more newer problems/challenges are added to kids lives these days. Parents these days too are obsessed abt many things and too much information abt everything is making them anxious and stressed. But is there a solution to this obsession? Can we stop worrying abt every single thing revolving around our kids? Well I guess it's a trade-off here as to how much knowledge to retain and how much to ignore for own peace and sanity:)
     
  5. jayasala42

    jayasala42 IL Hall of Fame

    Messages:
    5,367
    Likes Received:
    10,570
    Trophy Points:
    438
    Gender:
    Female
    Dear Bhargavi,
    You have taken an essential topic, the most relevant to modern days for discussion and
    it is a lovely presentation viewing the topic in multiple angles. A great job!

    As rightly observed one would long to be a parent of 1960s, when mothers brought up 5 children and mostly well disciplined.There was nothing in the society to corrupt or transform children.The only worry was to have money to feed the kids.Once stomach needs were taken care of, other mental and intellectual needs got fulfilled automatically.
    Now there is no dearth of money.But scientific advancements which are considered as developments, have actually become a curse in some other way.
    Parents themselves are becoming addicts to those electronic media, but they want to control the kids.Parents can't but feel anxious about the kids and can't reconcile if the child goes astray.
    Child upbringing books are available in plenty according to age.But no single solution will suit different kids or the same kid at different situations.
    Parents should know to keep themselves mentally in the place of children,assess every situation without prejudice.
    More often parents are blamed for taking credit for the achievement of children and for
    being guilty when the child goes wrong.After all they are human beings with sentiments and emotions.They are entitled to feel proud of the child to the extent of not making the children haughty.
    Any responsible parent would feel guilty if their sincere attempts to bring up the child in a proper manner miserably fail.Who else is to blame? Anxiety is a sign of responsibility
    as long as the parents are sincere enough to find ways and means to rectify themselves and strive for the betterment of the children ensuring that the anxiety does not harm themselves or the kids.
    Sometimes reference to Google Guru in shaping the kids proves a total flop,since no two kids are the same .

    Ignorance is bliss.But parents can't afford to be ignorant of communication advancements .Otherwise they would become incompetent to assess when, where and how to make a full stop to certain situations.Psychiatric intervention proves miserable to certain kids and makes situation worse in some cases.
    A child of 8 was referred to a psychiatrist in New Jersey some 12 years back. The parents got panicky when the situation turned worse, took a decision to return to India.The child is absolutely normal in India, no psychiatric counselling.The child is well disciplined and is now in the 3rd year of Engineering degree.
    Another parent also followed the same method.Unfortunately it didn't work out.With all the counsellings and best treatment in India, the child ,now 20, is too calm, or extremely ferocious, unable to have any formal education since the child causes harm to other kids or becomes a subject of mockery.Even in special school, no visible improvement is seen. How can a parent remain calm without getting anxious?As the parents are nearing 50 they are worried as to who would take care of the child after their time,the sibling having taken up a job and settled somewhere.The parents do not want to entrust the responsibility on the other child.They are happy that at least the other son is settled.
    There are multiple areas without any feasible solutions.parents in real life situations, who actually experience the hardships deserve not only lip sympathy , but need some
    practical help, not in the form of arm-chair advices which exist in plenty , but real solutions
    In spite of all these challenges ,parenthood is a blessing,since it gives meaning to life and keeps us learners for ever. The average, less intelligent, and less obedient children
    make us better thoughtful parents than the bright, obedient and disciplined ones.

    Jayasala42
     
  6. Bhargavi03

    Bhargavi03 Gold IL'ite

    Messages:
    143
    Likes Received:
    169
    Trophy Points:
    100
    Gender:
    Female
    @jayasala42 Hi Jayasala, thank you for that amazing outlay of thoughts articulated with a whole new vision and insight into multiple issues.
    Yes, in today's world as parents ourselves, we cannot stop clinging to advancing technology and electronic gadgets. Thereby kids are having an easy reach to these sources..so I guess keeping in mind about the well being of our kids, perhaps we as parents should be more cautious and cognizant abt its usage optimally and restrict it whenever needed. Afterall we should preach what we practice and serve as an example to our kids..
    Following the theoretical tips in Google to handle kids has not helped me much either with my son... Every child's psychology and mental growth & maturity is different. So over careful observations and evaluations we should find our own solutions to meet the challenges in child upbringing..
    Although i would resent to take blame on us as parents due to the failure of a child, yet we cannot stop being anxious and not just blame the destiny..
    I really loved ur ending - "The average, less intelligent, and less obedient children
    make us better thoughtful parents than the bright, obedient and disciplined ones.,"
    This is totally true. Unless we falter and make mistakes we can never learn and evolve into better people.
     
    Viswamitra and shyamala1234 like this.
  7. satchitananda

    satchitananda IL Hall of Fame

    Messages:
    17,880
    Likes Received:
    25,954
    Trophy Points:
    590
    Gender:
    Female
    Welcome back Bhargavi. Absolutely loved your post. This is something I keep saying, wondering what it is with the children of today. Why have they become so hypersensitive or is it that they have become more manipulative, threatening to run away / to commit suicide or actually doing it, often for something as trivial as being scolded in school or at home, not getting marks etc.?

    Parenting has become more complex and so has the job of a teacher. Earlier parents did not think twice before whacking a kid who was off track. I don't say that was a great thing, having been a the receiving end of it many times (and the humiliation of it has stayed to date - so I know what I am talking about) but it did not drive us to suicide. Nor did the humiliation heaped on us by teachers of yore. I am glad that corporal punishment is passé but things have now reached the other extreme. A child should not be corrected. With very few children, over-protective parents are loath to correct their own child (or is it that they don't see their faults at all?) Not just that, they don't accept teachers correcting their kids either. Mollycoddling kids like this is certainly not helping greatly.

    With the standard of living being higher today than what it was in previous times and with the advent of technology and technological gadgets, kids are not being trained to hear 'no'. Whatever they want is available on demand. Peer pressure is being pandered to. We too experienced peer pressure (albeit for smaller things) in our times, but the parents were in charge of deciding what was genuinely necessary and what one could live without. A watch was a luxury item as far as a kid was concerned and it was given only when the kid had to write a board exam or passed one with flying colours. Sure, mobiles have their advantages, but do kids really need high-end androids? Isn't a simple mobile sufficient, just to be able to ensure safety of kids and for them to be able to call up parents in case of dire necessity? Why are they not taught that the basic purpose of a mobile is to be able to make calls and that they should use them only for that purpose and not keep playing with androids/i-phones in class?

    Who is to blame? This IS NOT A BLAME GAME. However, it is also essential to fix degrees of responsibility on different parties to ensure that a system - in this case effective disciplining and upbringing of children - works well.

    1. The Kids: Well, kids will be kids ..... unless brought up right and taught responsibility, values etc. during their formative years. There are plenty of kids who are amazingly smart and responsible as opposed to the kind of kids I have mentioned in the above paras. However, kids are a product of their upbringing first at home and then in school.

    2. The Teachers: They are very important influences in the lives of kids especially during the formative years. How many times have we heard from kids 'But my teacher said .....'? Teachers, in their eyes, (at least when they are very young) can never be wrong. Teachers know everything. But in the current situation with 60-65 kids in one class, how much can one expect from them? Not to mention the hundreds of controls on their handling kids. (I don't deny that one needs to protect kids from a handful of perverted teachers, but that means that even well-intentioned teachers would be worried about correcting kids). So that means that they will revert to the parents in case there is some issue somewhere.

    3. The Parents: So whether we like it or not, the ultimate responsibility has to lie with the parents. What we need is a good, common-sense based approach to bringing up children rather than any fancy child psychology, which carried to an extreme can only produce kids who are weak and/or manipulative. Not to forget the need for parents to realize that kids are not means through which to live their own unfulfilled goals and ambitions vicariously but living, breathing human with their own capacities and limitations. What we need badly is to find a balance in our lives and to realize that life is not defined solely by academic excellence. Give those kids a break and help them grow as individuals with a sense of responsibility towards themselves as well as those around them. Make them human beings first and great academics later.
     
    Last edited: Sep 22, 2017
  8. Bhargavi03

    Bhargavi03 Gold IL'ite

    Messages:
    143
    Likes Received:
    169
    Trophy Points:
    100
    Gender:
    Female
    @satchitananda , Thanks a lot. I really loved every bit of your comments and do appreciate the time taken to pen them down. Most of your words were kind of a reflecting mirror to me because I am facing some of these with my son too. He is very sensitive and even a slightest degree of my voice raise is totally unacceptable to him. He is less than six so for now he only cries and throws up tantrums. ( Donno when he would start talking back). I am a cool as well as a strict mother when situation or things demand. I really face a challenge in pointing out mistakes or in convincing/coaxing him when he is wrong.. again he is a single child to me and although I try my best not to pamper him, he is smart and aware that he is my whole world and knows how to work his way around with me despite my efforts not to yield to it or to his demands..
    About the teachers, yes I totally agree that the teachers these days anticipate parents to be responsible and take up ownership for every thing, what's worse even when they expect the parents to prepare their kids abt some subjects much before even they're taught at school, in a way easing their job.
    The IQ level of these days kids are immensely high and they are very sharp and observant. Even I used to wonder if our endurance level was higher towards our parents punishments on us or were we thick skinned we definitely do not break down so easily and never in our dreams would imagine to run away from home or threaten to commit suicide for issues bothering us.
    I leave it to time and take life as it comes.. right now I deal with my son's issues one at a time. If my solution to my son's problems back lashes at me, I sit back and think through a whole new paradigm or at times simply give up to time
     
    Viswamitra and satchitananda like this.
  9. VaishaliYadav

    VaishaliYadav Senior IL'ite

    Messages:
    43
    Likes Received:
    15
    Trophy Points:
    23
    Gender:
    Female
    I completely agree with your argument. The present kids are sharper than us in their age. Sometimes i get amazed the way they learn everything fast. My nephew is 10 years old, sometimes he teach me about present technologies. At such acts i feel proud of him, but he is not ready to face problems. He often threatens his parents that he will commit suicide. how to handle these kind of kids??? He is sharp at his educational activities with weak mental strength.
     
  10. Thyagarajan

    Thyagarajan IL Hall of Fame

    Messages:
    11,723
    Likes Received:
    12,546
    Trophy Points:
    615
    Gender:
    Male
    :hello:@Bhargavi03 superb handling of the theme. profound thinking and critical analysis must have gone into this for posting such a thought provoking thread. Kudos to the author Bhargavi03. she had projected the issue, problems and settled the subject in that penultimate para when and how one can transfer the parenting as boon forever. God Bless us all. thank You and Regards.
     
    Bhargavi03 likes this.

Share This Page